Why Your PhD Needs a Pause: Practicing Kindfulness Through Finals and Beyond
Every week, I meet with graduate students who are somewhere along their PhD journey. Some are working in a difficult lab. Some have research that isn't working out the way they hoped. Others are quietly questioning themselves: Did I choose the right path in pursuing a PhD in the first place?
I remember one client in particular who told me that the stress of her PhD left her feeling less confident by the end than when she first began. I've heard variations of this theme many times. What I find is that students drift from the very things that bring them joy in life, like connecting with others, keeping up with a hobby, and practicing self-care. They also lose touch with what drew them to this work in the first place: finding meaning and joy in some aspect of it.
I, too, was once a PhD student navigating the peaks and valleys of the various requirements. Early on in the path, there is coursework and managing midterms, papers, and final exams. Eventually come qualifying exams, and then, of course, independent research.
In the three decades since that time, the one skill I am most grateful to have learned in my late 20s is mindfulness. At the time, the practice was considered fringe and new age. I still remember one of my professors remarking that my interest in mind-body medicine was flaky. Of course, that couldn't be further from the truth. In the years since, mindfulness practices have become standard behavioral health interventions, and many hospitals across the world have mind-body centers.
Over time, I learned the hard way, by not paying attention to my stress and the physical symptoms related to it, that I also needed to add another component: self-compassion. What strikes me in working with Harvard students earning their PhDs now is that the student experience hasn’t changed. Stress levels remain very high, and the very foundations of overall well-being often fall by the wayside, including quality sleep, adequate movement and physical activity, regular and healthy meals, and a few high-quality social supports.
What happens when people get stressed? They don't sleep well. They skip the gym. They start eating less or gravitate to comfort food. And they isolate themselves.
From Mindfulness to Kindfulness
The classic definition of mindfulness comes from Jon Kabat-Zinn: "paying attention on purpose, in the present moment, and without judgment." In 1979, he started the Stress Reduction Clinic at the University of Massachusetts Medical Center in the basement of a hospital building. Other doctors referred the patients they felt they could no longer help, largely people living with chronic pain. What we have learned since then is that mindfulness helps with so much more, including anxiety, depression, inner critical narratives, physical well-being, and emotion regulation.
The psychologist and meditation teacher, Tara Brach, brings in the notion of compassion for oneself while struggling with the daily hassles of life or our emotional demons. In her 2003 book, Radical Acceptance, Brach describes the two wings of a bird. One wing is mindfulness, or clear seeing. The other is compassion, our capacity to hold what we see with tenderness. A bird needs both wings to fly. Awareness without warmth can leave us coolly observing our own suffering, and warmth without clear seeing can lead to poor boundaries and burnout.
I myself came to use the term kindfulness, which I define as "being aware of the present moment with heart." It's the difference between noticing "I'm panicking about this exam" and noticing it with the same care you would offer a friend who said those words to you.
The Power of a Pause
A pause can make a big difference. Without one, we tend to react instinctively and protectively to whatever feels like a threat, whether that is a harsh comment from a reviewer, an experiment that failed again, or a blank page the night before a deadline. With a pause, we give ourselves enough headspace to engage the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain involved in emotion regulation and perspective taking. Then we can respond with clarity rather than reflex. Tara Brach calls this the "sacred pause." Sharon Salzberg, who introduced the Western world to loving-kindness meditation, another Buddhist practice of directing well wishes, describes the pause as the “magic moment.” A little bit of spaciousness for caring attention toward yourself and others. Often, all you need is your breath. The trick is to practice the pause repeatedly throughout your week.
In my book The Kindness Cure, I describe a number of simple tools for cultivating kindfulness in everyday life. Here are two you can practice as you approach final exams, or launch into whatever phase of your graduate journey comes next.
Practice 1: A Kindful Breath
Taking three deep breaths is a portal to being present. It's one of the kindest things you can do for yourself.
- Find a comfortable place to sit or lie down, feeling your body supported by the floor or a chair. You can also stand quietly, supported by a wall. Place your hands on your lower belly, on your heart, in your lap, or at your sides. Close your eyes, if you like.
- Take deep breaths that fill your diaphragm. Breathe in, down to the bottom of your lungs, and notice your belly expand. Exhale and release. Repeat.
- Breathe in a natural and gentle way, the way a sleeping baby or a contented cat does. Follow the rhythm of your body rising and falling.
- Turn toward yourself with kind awareness. You might imagine being wrapped in a warm blanket.
- If it helps, quietly say "peace" on the inhale and "calm" on the exhale. Or try a phrase like "I am okay" or "I hold myself with tenderness."
Start with three breaths. Over time, you may want to stretch this to five or ten minutes.
Practice 2: One Breath for Me, One Breath for You
Once you are comfortable working with your breath, try this simple compassion practice for harder moments. It's a variation of tonglen, a Buddhist giving-and-receiving meditation, and it's especially helpful when you notice that you and the people around you are all running on empty.
- Sit quietly, perhaps with a hand on your heart, and breathe comfortably.
- Bring to mind a sense of warmth, comfort, and ease, or whatever you need in this moment. Inhale this soothing feeling for yourself.
- Now bring to mind someone who is also struggling. Maybe it's a lab mate, a cohort friend, or a family member far away. On the exhale, offer them kindness, comfort, and ease.
- Continue in an even flow, like a seesaw. One breath in for me, one breath out for you.
Practice 3: A Short Loving-Kindness Practice
Loving-kindness is one of the oldest compassion practices. It gently widens the circle of care, starting with yourself, then reaching toward someone else, and finally including all of us. It takes about a minute, so you can try it between classes or as you settle into sleep.
- Find a comfortable position and take a few easy breaths. Place a hand on your heart, if that feels supportive.
- Begin with yourself. Silently offer: "May I be happy. May I feel safe. May I experience joy."
- Bring to mind someone you care about, or someone who is having a hard time. Offer them the same wishes: "May you be happy. May you feel safe. May you experience joy."
- Now widen the circle to include your lab, your cohort, and everyone on campus heading into finals: "May we be happy. May we feel safe. May we experience joy."
- Rest for a breath or two and notice how you feel.
Small Pauses, Big Difference
You don't need a meditation cushion or an extra hour to practice. Look for natural pauses already built into your day: before you open an exam, while your code compiles, before you hit send on a chapter draft to your advisor, or while you wait in line for coffee. Research shows that just 20-30 seconds of a compassionate gesture, like a hand over the heart or a self-hug, done consistently over a month has benefits for wellbeing. I call these moments micro-doses of self-compassion.
A kindful pause is also a chance to check in on the basics that stress tends to push aside. Am I hungry? Am I exhausted? When did I last move my body, or talk to someone who makes me laugh? Asking these questions with kindness, rather than as another item on your to-do list, can help you take care of yourself in small, doable ways. If you live by your to-do list, you may notice that rest, meals, and time with friends begin to disappear, or they get bumped to “after I finish this chapter.” The truth is the list never really ends, and skipping the basics makes every item on it even harder. So take the self-care pause.
And if your stress feels like more than a few breaths can hold, please reach out. Talking with someone at Harvard's Counseling and Mental Health Services (CAMHS) is another powerful way to pause. You can schedule an initial consultation directly through the HUHS Patient Portal or by calling the CAMHS front desk at 617-495-2042, option 1. You can also attend a 4-week Introduction to Mindfulness series through the Center for Wellness and Health Promotion at the start of a new semester.
You can get through this season, one breath at a time. The pauses add up.